Click here to get your
free subscription!
        Don't Ask, Don't Tell?

By: Shannon Southerland

We live in a time of increasing
tolerance toward people, cultures,
and lifestyles different of our own.
When it comes to being gay, there
are television shows, nationwide
celebrations and advocacy groups
promoting gay rights, and some
states even allow gays to marry.
Yet there is one area that has
continued to have a no-tolerance
policy toward homosexuality. That
is the military, where for decades
homosexuals have been denied the
right to openly serve our country.
However, with a new president now
in office, this issue is getting
brought up in hopes of repealing it
and making an open military where anyone can serve.

The Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell policy was introduced in 1993 by President
Bill Clinton, with the goal of letting anyone serve in the military
regardless of their sexual orientation. However, Congress overrode
President Clinton’s idea and added their own clause: “Don’t Ask,”
meaning officials cannot ask or require military persons to disclose
their sexual orientation, and “Don’t Tell,” meaning that military
persons may be discharged if they state that they are homosexual or
bisexual and/or have or intend to engage in homosexual activities.

Since this policy was enacted, more than 13,500 military personnel
have been fired from their position due to sexual orientation. In
January, 11 soldiers were discharged from the Army for being gay.
Currently, over two dozen countries, including Great Britain and
Canada, allow gays to serve openly without threat of discharge. Of
these countries that allow open service, studies have shown no
negative effects on enrollment or military service.     

President Barack Obama is calling for repeal on the Don’t Ask, Don’t
Tell policy, saying during the State of the Union Address in January
that he will work with Congress and our military to finally repeal the
law that denies gay Americans the right to serve the country they love
because of who they are.”1 He had made similar comments in other
speeches, but this was the first time in which he committed to a
timeline. After this address, the Human Rights Campaign responded by
announcing the Voices of Honor Campaign, to help make open military
service become a reality.

An Army soldier and ROTC instructor, both who requested anonymity,
agreed that it was time for a change with the policy; they had seen or
known of good soldiers who have been discharged due to the policy.
However, they did say that it was not as simple as just repealing the
law. This would cause lots of changes in how the military runs. Just
one example was in training. Instead of just the standard sensitivity
and sexual harassment classes, the military would have to create
classes and training that pertained to homosexual harassment. They
also felt that if the policy does get repealed making the change to open
service should not be a problem. “If the policy does get repealed as it
should, the United States should be able to make a peaceful transition
just like the German and Dutch militaries did,” they said.   

Currently in Congress, the Secretary of Defense has requested that the
repeal of this law be put on hold until the Defense Department can
complete its yearlong review, scheduled for December 1, 2010.
Although work is being done to repeal the Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell policy,
it still will be a long process, one that hopefully will result in open
service for anyone no matter what their sexual orientation may be.